The 1985 Discovery of Buckminsterfullerene: First Fullerene Molecule of Carbon and a Revolution in Modern Chemistry

The Discovery of Buckminsterfullerene in 1985: A Scientific Breakthrough in Carbon Chemistry

In the year 1985, an extraordinary scientific discovery transformed our understanding of carbon, one of the most fundamental elements of life and matter. This was the year when Buckminsterfullerene, commonly known as C₆₀ or “buckyballs,” was first identified as a new allotrope of carbon. The discovery, made by a team of researchers including Harold Kroto, Richard Smalley, Robert Curl, James Heath, and Sean O’Brien, introduced the world to a completely novel molecular structure: a closed cage of sixty carbon atoms arranged in the shape of a truncated icosahedron, resembling the panels of a soccer ball or the architectural geodesic domes designed by R. Buckminster Fuller, from whom the molecule takes its name.

This event marked a turning point in chemistry, physics, and materials science. Until that moment, carbon was believed to exist naturally only in three allotropes: diamond, graphite, and amorphous carbon. The sudden revelation that carbon atoms could arrange themselves into hollow spherical molecules with remarkable symmetry opened new directions in nanotechnology, materials engineering, superconductivity, and even medicine. It also earned Kroto, Smalley, and Curl the 1996 Nobel Prize in Chemistry.

The story of Buckminsterfullerene is not only about scientific ingenuity but also about serendipity, interdisciplinary collaboration, and the curiosity-driven exploration of molecular structures in the vastness of interstellar space. To understand the complete details of this discovery, one must examine the background of carbon chemistry, the experimental work that led to its identification, the subsequent confirmation and isolation of fullerenes, their properties, and the revolutionary impact they have had on science and technology.

Carbon: The Element of Life and Diversity

Carbon, with the atomic number 6, is unique among the elements for its ability to form a vast array of compounds. This versatility stems from its electron configuration, which allows it to form four covalent bonds with other atoms, including other carbon atoms. The strength of carbon–carbon bonds and the element’s capacity to form chains, rings, and complex structures underpin the entire field of organic chemistry.

Before 1985, carbon was understood to exist in three main allotropes:

1. Diamond – where each carbon atom is tetrahedrally bonded to four others, producing a three-dimensional crystal lattice responsible for diamond’s hardness and transparency.

2. Graphite – where carbon atoms are arranged in hexagonal sheets held together by weak van der Waals forces, giving graphite its lubricating properties and electrical conductivity.

3. Amorphous carbon – non-crystalline forms such as soot, coal, or charcoal.

There were also forms such as carbon black and glassy carbon, but they were considered variations of the amorphous state. The idea that carbon could form stable, hollow spherical molecules was unanticipated by most chemists, although there had been occasional hints and speculations.

Scientific Background Leading to the Discovery

The origins of the fullerene discovery lie in two fields: astrophysics and laser spectroscopy.

Harold Kroto’s Interest in Interstellar Chemistry

Harold W. Kroto, a British chemist from the University of Sussex, had been investigating the chemical composition of interstellar clouds. Spectroscopic observations of giant stars and nebulae revealed unusual absorption lines in the microwave region, which suggested the presence of carbon chains like HC₅N, HC₇N, and HC₉N in outer space. Kroto was fascinated by the possibility that long carbon chains might play a role in cosmic chemistry and even in the origins of life.

Kroto wanted to replicate the conditions of carbon-rich stars in the laboratory, particularly the environment where carbon atoms condense from high-temperature plasmas. However, he lacked the necessary experimental tools.

Richard Smalley and Robert Curl at Rice University

Meanwhile, at Rice University in Houston, Texas, Richard E. Smalley, a physical chemist specializing in laser spectroscopy, and his colleague Robert F. Curl had developed a unique laser-supersonic cluster beam apparatus. This device could vaporize atoms from a solid sample using a powerful laser pulse and then cool them rapidly in a supersonic helium jet, creating clusters of atoms that could be analyzed using time-of-flight mass spectrometry.

Smalley’s apparatus was initially designed to study metal clusters, but when Kroto visited Rice in 1985, he realized that this setup was ideal for simulating the conditions of carbon condensation in stars. He persuaded Smalley and Curl to try carbon as a target material. This collaboration set the stage for the historic discovery.

The Experiment of 1985

The decisive experiments were carried out in September 1985 at Rice University. The team consisted of Harold Kroto, Richard Smalley, Robert Curl, graduate student James R. Heath, and postdoctoral researcher Sean O’Brien.

The Experimental Setup

• A powerful pulsed laser was directed at a rotating graphite disk inside a vacuum chamber.

• The laser ablation vaporized carbon atoms from the surface, creating a hot plasma.

• A high-pressure helium gas jet then cooled the vapor, allowing carbon atoms to condense into clusters.

• The clusters were carried into a time-of-flight mass spectrometer, which measured their mass distribution.

The Surprising Result

The mass spectrum revealed peaks corresponding to various carbon clusters, but one particular peak stood out: a strong signal at 720 atomic mass units (amu). Since the atomic weight of carbon is 12, this corresponded to 60 carbon atoms (C₆₀).

Another strong peak appeared at 840 amu (C₇₀), but C₆₀ was by far the most prominent. Even more intriguing was the stability of this molecule; it dominated the cluster distribution even when the experimental conditions were varied.

The Puzzle of Structure

At first, the researchers were puzzled as to why C₆₀ appeared so abundantly. Most cluster distributions show a smooth decline with size, not a sharp preference for a specific number. The stability of C₆₀ suggested a highly symmetric and closed structure.

Through discussions and brainstorming, the team proposed that C₆₀ must be arranged in a hollow spherical cage, with 60 carbon atoms forming 12 pentagons and 20 hexagons—the same geometry as a truncated icosahedron. This structure was strikingly similar to the geodesic domes designed by the American architect and futurist R. Buckminster Fuller. In honor of his pioneering designs, the molecule was named Buckminsterfullerene.

The paper announcing this discovery, titled “C₆₀: Buckminsterfullerene,” was published in Nature in November 1985.

Naming and Geometric Inspiration

The name Buckminsterfullerene captured both the molecular geometry and the cultural resonance of the discovery.

• Truncated Icosahedron Geometry: The C₆₀ molecule is shaped like a soccer ball, composed of 60 vertices (carbon atoms), 32 faces (12 pentagons and 20 hexagons), and 90 edges (bonds). Each carbon atom is bonded to three others, making the structure exceptionally stable.

• Connection to R. Buckminster Fuller: Fuller’s geodesic domes, developed in the mid-20th century, were based on similar geometric principles of distributing stress evenly across a spherical framework. Although Fuller himself was not directly involved in the discovery, his architectural vision had inspired the language and imagery that the scientists used to describe the molecule.

The shorter name “fullerene” was later adopted to describe the entire family of such carbon molecules, including C₆₀, C₇₀, and larger or smaller cages.

Verification and Expansion of the Discovery

The initial 1985 experiment produced only minute quantities of C₆₀, insufficient for detailed study. Many chemists were skeptical about the actual structure, since no direct structural determination had been made at that time.

Wolfgang Krätschmer and Donald Huffman’s Contribution

The breakthrough came in 1990, when Wolfgang Krätschmer and Donald Huffman developed a method to produce macroscopic amounts of C₆₀. By striking an electric arc between graphite electrodes in a helium atmosphere, they generated soot containing significant amounts of C₆₀ and C₇₀. The fullerenes could then be extracted using organic solvents such as benzene or toluene, which dissolved the molecules.

With this method, researchers could now obtain crystalline samples of C₆₀, perform X-ray diffraction, and confirm definitively that the structure matched the proposed truncated icosahedron.

This discovery validated the Rice University team’s hypothesis and opened the floodgates for fullerene research worldwide.

The Nobel Prize in Chemistry, 1996

The significance of the fullerene discovery was quickly recognized. In 1996, Harold Kroto, Richard Smalley, and Robert Curl were awarded the Nobel Prize in Chemistry “for their discovery of fullerenes.”

Notably, James Heath and Sean O’Brien, the younger members of the team who had performed much of the experimental work, were not included in the Nobel recognition, a decision that generated debate in the scientific community. Nevertheless, the award cemented the status of the discovery as one of the great milestones in modern chemistry.

Properties of Buckminsterfullerene

The discovery of C₆₀ revealed a molecule with remarkable physical and chemical properties.

Structural Properties

• Symmetry: C₆₀ has icosahedral symmetry, one of the highest possible symmetries for a molecule.

• Bonding: Each carbon atom forms three bonds, similar to graphite. The bonds are not all identical; some resemble double bonds while others are closer to single bonds, creating a delocalized electron system.

• Size: The diameter of the C₆₀ molecule is approximately 0.7 nanometers.

Physical Properties

• C₆₀ is soluble in certain organic solvents, producing a purple solution.

• It crystallizes into a face-centered cubic (fcc) lattice.

• It can withstand high pressures and temperatures, making it structurally robust.

Chemical Reactivity

• C₆₀ behaves like an electron-deficient alkene, capable of undergoing addition reactions.

• It can accept up to six electrons, forming stable anions.

• Derivatives of C₆₀ can be synthesized by functionalizing its surface with other atoms or groups.
  

The Fullerene Family

Although C₆₀ is the most famous, it is only one member of the fullerene family.

• C₇₀: A slightly elongated version of C₆₀.

• Higher fullerenes: C₇₆, C₈₄, C₉₀, and larger, often with less symmetry.

• Endohedral fullerenes: Fullerenes that encapsulate atoms or ions inside their cage, such as La@C₈₂.

• Carbon nanotubes: Discovered shortly after, these can be considered cylindrical fullerenes. They have extraordinary mechanical and electronic properties.

The discovery of fullerenes thus opened an entirely new field of carbon nanostructures.

Applications of Buckminsterfullerene

Since 1985, research into C₆₀ and related fullerenes has expanded dramatically, with applications across multiple disciplines.

Materials Science

• Superconductors: Alkali-metal-doped fullerenes (e.g., K₃C₆₀) exhibit superconductivity at relatively high temperatures (~30 K).

• Lubricants: The spherical shape of C₆₀ makes it act like a molecular ball bearing.

• Composite materials: Fullerenes can enhance the mechanical strength and resilience of polymers.

Electronics and Nanotechnology

• Organic photovoltaics: Fullerene derivatives such as PCBM are used as electron acceptors in organic solar cells.

• Transistors: Thin-film transistors have been fabricated using C₆₀.

• Molecular electronics: The delocalized electron system of fullerenes makes them candidates for nanoscale circuits.

Medicine and Biology

• Antioxidants: C₆₀ can act as a radical scavenger, neutralizing free radicals.

• Drug delivery: Functionalized fullerenes can encapsulate or attach therapeutic agents.

• Antiviral activity: Certain fullerene derivatives inhibit HIV protease.

• Diagnostics: Fullerenes have been explored as contrast agents in imaging.

Environmental Applications

• Fullerenes can adsorb pollutants and act as catalysts in environmental remediation.

Although many of these applications remain at the research stage, the potential of fullerenes continues to inspire new ideas in nanoscience.

The Broader Impact of the Discovery

The discovery of Buckminsterfullerene was not an isolated achievement but part of a broader transformation in the study of nanomaterials. It heralded the birth of nanotechnology as a field, by showing that molecules with precise nanoscale architectures could be synthesized and manipulated.

It also inspired a reconsideration of carbon chemistry. Alongside the later discovery of carbon nanotubes (1991) and graphene (2004), fullerenes completed the picture of carbon’s extraordinary versatility. These discoveries have fueled dreams of molecular electronics, quantum computing, space materials, and medical nanobots.

Cultural Resonance

The appeal of Buckminsterfullerene extended beyond the scientific community. Its iconic soccer-ball structure made it visually recognizable and even aesthetically pleasing. It appeared in art, popular science books, and media coverage. The connection to Buckminster Fuller, an architect known for his utopian visions, gave the molecule symbolic weight as a fusion of science, design, and futurism.

Fullerenes were sometimes referred to as “buckyballs,” a nickname that captured their playful geometry. They became a cultural icon of the 1990s, often cited as an example of how scientific discoveries can be beautiful as well as useful.

Continuing Research Directions

Even today, forty years after their discovery, fullerenes remain an active field of study. Research continues on:

• Fullerene-based superconductors with higher transition temperatures.

• Endohedral metallofullerenes, where trapped atoms impart magnetic or electronic properties.

• Biomedical applications of fullerene derivatives for cancer therapy, antiviral treatments, and targeted drug delivery.

• Photovoltaic efficiency, with fullerene derivatives improving organic solar cells.

• Quantum materials, where fullerenes serve as building blocks for new states of matter.

The story of Buckminsterfullerene thus remains unfinished, as its potential is still being realized.

Conclusion

The 1985 discovery of Buckminsterfullerene was a landmark in science, reshaping our understanding of carbon and inspiring whole new domains of research. What began as a quest to simulate interstellar chemistry led to the revelation of a new form of matter: a perfectly symmetrical, spherical molecule of 60 carbon atoms.

This discovery was remarkable not only for the molecule itself but also for what it represented: the power of interdisciplinary collaboration, the role of curiosity-driven research, and the unpredictable beauty of nature’s designs. By bridging astrophysics, chemistry, and materials science, the discovery of C₆₀ has had an impact far beyond its initial scope.

From Nobel Prizes to nanotechnology, from superconductors to medicine, from architecture to popular culture, Buckminsterfullerene has become a symbol of the creativity and interconnectedness of human inquiry. As researchers continue to unlock its potential, the “buckyball” stands as a reminder that even the simplest elements, like carbon, can hold secrets that change the world.

Photo from: Shutterstock

Share this

myearthisone