The Founding and Evolution of Brigham Young University: From its 1875 Inception in Provo to a Modern Global Institution

The Founding and Evolution of Brigham Young University: From a Small 1875 Academy to a Modern Global Institution

Brigham Young University (BYU) was founded on October 16, 1875, in Provo, Utah, as Brigham Young Academy by Brigham Young, the second president of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints. Established with the visionary purpose of providing an education "unmixed with the pernicious atheistic influences" found in other contemporary schools, its founding marked the beginning of an institution dedicated to fusing secular learning with religious principles. From its humble beginnings in a single building, BYU has grown into a large, private research university and the flagship educational institution of the Church Educational System . Its history is a story of resilience through financial and physical setbacks, a deliberate evolution from a small academy to a university of international stature, and an unwavering commitment to its unique spiritual and academic mission.

The Founding Vision and Early Context

The mid-19th century was a period where schools in the United States were becoming increasingly secular, a trend that deeply concerned Brigham Young. He did not believe in separating knowledge into "religious" and "secular" compartments. In a sermon, he declared, "If any of the Elders shall give us a lecture upon astronomy, chemistry, or geology, our religion embraces it all". This philosophy was the bedrock upon which the academy was built. Brigham Young intended the school to be a place where "the children of the Latter-day Saints can receive a good education unmixed with the pernicious atheistic influences that are found in so many of the higher schools of the country". In a letter to a teacher, he elaborated that the mission was to train students "to be Latter-day Saints... by teaching them the principles of truth, righteousness and virtue, and implanting within them the love of the principles of our holy religion". The founding of the Brigham Young Academy was not an isolated event but part of a broader educational initiative by Brigham Young, who also established the Young Academy in Salt Lake City in 1876 and the Brigham Young College in Logan in 1877 to propagate the same educational model.

The academy's origins can be traced to earlier educational efforts in Provo. In 1862, Warren Dusenberry started a school in Cluff Hall, which, despite its initial popularity, faced financial difficulties. In 1869, he and his brother Wilson started another school that gained such a strong reputation for quality that it was adopted as the Timpanogos branch of the University of Deseret. When this school also encountered financial troubles, Brigham Young deeded the property to trustees to create a new, independent Church school. The official founding date is October 16, 1875, and classes for the new Brigham Young Academy commenced on January 3, 1876. Warren Dusenberry served as interim principal until April 1876, when Brigham Young's chosen leader, Karl G. Maeser, arrived.

The Maeser Era: Institutionalizing the Foundational Model

Under the leadership of Principal Karl G. Maeser, a German immigrant and a devoted educator, Brigham Young Academy began to solidify its unique character. Maeser is famously reported to have said, "You ought not to teach even the alphabet or the multiplication tables without the Spirit of God," a principle that directly reflected Brigham Young's charge. He was a strict disciplinarian and a charismatic teacher who instilled in his students a deep sense of piety and scholarship. The academy, during its early years, functioned primarily as a secondary school, though it also offered collegiate-level coursework. The institution operated in the Lewis Building in downtown Provo, where it faced a significant crisis in January 1884 when a fire started in a chemistry lab and destroyed the building.

The response to this disaster demonstrated the community's commitment to the school. Classes were temporarily held in various locations, including a ZCMI warehouse, until a new, elaborate brick and sandstone building, called the BY Academy Building, was completed in 1892. It was during this period of recovery and growth that the academy was officially absorbed and sponsored by the LDS Church on July 18, 1896, securing its financial and institutional future. Maeser's tenure produced many successful graduates, including future U.S. Supreme Court Justice George Sutherland and U.S. Senator Reed Smoot, setting a high standard for academic excellence. In 1903, Maeser was succeeded by Benjamin Cluff, Jr., who ushered in a new era of expansion and ambition for the institution.

The Transition to a University

Benjamin Cluff's presidency was marked by a push toward modernization and a broader academic horizon. A graduate of the University of Michigan, Cluff introduced new ideas and methods, including the beginnings of an athletics program and a greater emphasis on higher-level coursework, effectively starting the separation of the college from the high school. His most enduring act, however, came at the end of his tenure. In 1903, following an expedition to Mexico that led to accusations of mismanagement (though he was cleared of all charges), Cluff proposed to the board of trustees that Brigham Young Academy be renamed "Brigham Young University".

This proposal was met with significant opposition, as some board members felt the school was not yet large enough to warrant the title of a university. As board member Anthon H. Lund remarked, "I hope their head will grow big enough for their hat". Despite this skepticism, the decision ultimately passed. Consequently, in 1903, Brigham Young Academy was formally dissolved and replaced by two distinct institutions: Brigham Young High School and Brigham Young University. The Board elected George H. Brimhall as the new president of BYU. A critical step in the university's growth was the 1904 purchase of 17 acres of land known as "Temple Hill" in Provo. This land, which many had presumed would host a future LDS temple, became the site of the modern BYU campus. Construction began on the first building, the Karl G. Maeser Memorial, in 1909, firmly establishing the university's new home.

A Period of Growth and Challenge

The early university years under Presidents Brimhall and Franklin S. Harris were formative. President Brimhall's tenure saw the hiring of faculty with high credentials, including several PhDs, which elevated the academic rigor of the school . However, this period was also marked by contention. A crisis emerged when some faculty advocated for teaching the theory of evolution, while others disagreed. The issue was settled by LDS Church President Joseph F. Smith, who asked that evolution not be taught at the school. The ensuing fallout led to the firing of two faculty members and the resignation of several others. Despite this challenge, which led some to describe BYU as little more than a "religious seminary," the university's graduates continued to achieve success and renown, and the institution persisted.

A major turning point came with the appointment of Franklin S. Harris as president in 1921. Harris was the first BYU president to hold a doctoral degree, and his 24-year tenure transformed the institution. He reorganized the college into a true university structure and relentlessly pursued accreditation. By the end of his term, BYU was accredited by all major accrediting organizations, granting it national recognition and legitimacy. The post-World War II era brought an unprecedented influx of students. Under President Howard S. McDonald, enrollment grew nearly fivefold to 5,440 students, overwhelming the university's facilities. To cope, the university purchased part of an Air Force Base in Ogden, Utah, to house students. This period of intense growth continued under President Ernest L. Wilkinson, who oversaw an accelerated building program that added over eighty structures to the campus. During his administration, the student body increased six-fold, making BYU the largest private university in the nation at the time.

BYU in the Modern Era

The latter half of the 20th century and the early 21st century saw BYU solidify its status as a major university. Under President Dallin H. Oaks, a law school was added, and a new library was constructed. President Jeffrey R. Holland emphasized the combination of educational excellence and religious faith, a theme that has continued to define the university's identity. It was during his administration that the BYU Jerusalem Center was established. Subsequent presidents, including Rex E. Lee, Merrill J. Bateman, and Kevin J Worthen, have each overseen significant expansions in campus infrastructure, academic programs, and research capabilities. On May 1, 2023, C. Shane Reese became BYU's 14th president. In a significant announcement on July 29, 2024, the First Presidency of the Church disclosed plans to create a medical school for the university, pointing toward an ambitious future.

Today, the main campus in Provo sits on approximately 560 acres at the base of the Wasatch Mountains and includes 295 buildings . The university offers a wide variety of academic programs through its 11 colleges and schools. It holds an "R1" Carnegie classification, indicating a very high level of research activity. As of fall 2024, total enrollment was 35,743 students. A defining characteristic of the modern BYU is its honor code, which students agree to follow. This code mandates behaviors in line with LDS Church teachings, including academic honesty, dress and grooming standards, and abstinence from alcohol, illicit drugs, and extramarital sex. The university's global impact is reflected in its diverse student body and alumni network; nearly 50% of its students have lived outside the United States, and 65% speak a second language. Its alumni, numbering in the hundreds of thousands, have achieved prominence in fields as varied as government, science, literature, entertainment, and professional sports.

From its founding in 1875 as a small academy designed to provide a spiritually-grounded education, Brigham Young University has navigated challenges and seized opportunities to become a world-class university. Its journey from a single building in downtown Provo to a vast campus with international centers and a reputation for high research activity is a testament to the enduring power of its original mission. The vision of its founder, Brigham Young, and the dedication of leaders like Karl G. Maeser, continue to guide the university as it seeks to integrate all fields of human knowledge with the principles of the gospel of Jesus Christ.

Share this

myearthisone